Abu Bakar Siddique | Dhaka Tribune | May 3, 2015

Nine Indian citizens move an environment court, seeking over Rs3,000 crore in annual compensation for the devastation caused by the barrage


The Farraka barrage has caused devastation, not only in Bangladesh, but also in India, according to a writ petition filed at the end of last year.

The plight of Bangladeshi farmers, who lived in the basin areas and suffered dislocation by the drying up of the river, is well known.

But in late December 2014, nine Indian citizens – including fishermen and environmentalists – filed a writ petition with the National Green Tribunal of India against different government agencies, claiming annual compensation for the economic and geological damage caused inside India, including that caused by Farakka.

The tribunal heard and accepted the petition on January 16 this year, one of the petitioners told the Dhaka Tribune.

According to the petition, a copy of which is available with the Dhaka Tribune, the applicants are residents of Kakdwip, Kolkata, Uttarakhand, South Malda, Bihar, Murshidabad and Allahabad.

The petition says that, among other authorities, the Farakka barrage project is liable for environmental losses of Rs3,226 crore annually.

This is the first ever litigation of this magnitude on the Farakka barrage issue in either of the two countries.

The petition

The trans-boundary Ganges flows through India and Bangladesh. The 2,525km river rises in the western Himalayas in the Indian state of Uttarakhand, and flows south and east through the Gangetic Plain of north India into Bangladesh.

The petition says that half a billion people – nearly one-tenth of the world’s population – live in the Ganges River basin and depend on the river directly and indirectly for their livelihood.

The applicants submit that the construction of hydro-engineering structures such as dams, barrages and embankments have greatly hampered the livelihoods of a large number of people including pilgrims, poor people living on the Ganges banks and fishing communities. 

Citing a February 2014 report of the Kolkata-based Central Inland Fisheries Research Institute (CIFRI), the petitioners say the fishing potential of the lower reaches of the river is estimated at almost 200kg per hectare per year, whereas the actual yield is 30kg.

This means that barely 15% of the production potential can now be harvested because the rivers are degraded.

The writ petition also says that dams have become a major impediment in ensuring continuous freshwater flow in rivers. As a result, the habitat requirements of fishes in the rivers for feeding, migration, spawning and growth have been irreparably altered.

The construction of the Farakka barrage in 1975 at the head of the Bhagirathi and Padma tributaries of the Ganges, some 470km from the mouth of the river, has not affected the fishing of Ilish, a popular fish in both Bangladesh and West Bengal, in the tidal stretch of the delta.

However, the barrage has nearly eliminated the riverine fishery upstream in the main stream of the Ganges.

Bangladesh’s woes

Experts on trans-boundary rivers say Bangladesh is caught on the wrong side of an “if” that appears in a bilateral water-sharing treaty.

A key point in the 1996 water-sharing agreement says that “if there is water,” then India and Bangladesh will alternatively receive 35,000 cubic litres of water per second (cusec) over 10-day periods from March 11 and May 10 every year.

However, data from the Joint River Commission (JRC) shows that Bangladesh, a lower riparian country, has often been deprived of the projected volume of water during lean periods.

For example, Bangladesh received the guaranteed volume in 2014, but the flows in 2008, 2009 and 2011 have been less.

Environmental lawyer and activist Syeda Rizwana Hasan said: “If India, an upper riparian of the Ganges, has faced difficulties, then the fate of Bangladesh as the lower riparian of Farakka, is easily understandable.”

Original Article posted in Dhaka Tribune


Minutes of Meeting with World Bank-2nd September, 2015
Saturday, 12 September 2015
A meeting was held with World Bank officials on 2 September, 2015. Representations: Jayanto Bandopadhyaya, Vimal Bhai, Prahlad Goenka, Bharat... Read More...
Representation to World Bank on TORs for NW-1 Studies
Tuesday, 25 August 2015
August 13, 2015 Shri Arnab Bandopadhyay The World Bank New Delhi My Dear Arnab: We write in continuation of our earlier interactions regarding NW-1.... Read More...
Comments on TOR for NW-1 Studies Submitted to Inland Waterways Authority of India
Tuesday, 25 August 2015
DR BHARAT JHUNJHUNWALA Lakshmoli, PO Maletha, Via Kirti Nagar, Dt Tehri UK 249 161 Phone: 99171-44777; Email: [email protected] August 13, 2015 Shri... Read More...
IMAGE Ganga Rejuvenation Must Go Beyond Lip Service
Saturday, 18 October 2014
Bharat Lal Seth | Fri, 10/17/2014 - 3:35pm | International Rivers   The rejuvenation of the Ganga figured prominently in the manifesto of the... Read More...
IMAGE Let the River Take its Course
Tuesday, 30 September 2014
Written by Ramaswamy R Iyer | Posted: September 30, 2014 2:10 am | The Indian Express Soon after the prime minister assumed... Read More...
IMAGE World Rivers Day and Ganga: A look at Farakka Barrage and other such calamities
Tuesday, 30 September 2014
Parineeta Dandekar | 29th September, 2014 | SANDRP   Last Sunday of every September is celebrated as ‘World Rivers Day’. It is a recent... Read More...
Water resources depleting in Ganga catchment area: Study
Wednesday, 12 August 2015
B.D. Kasniyal | The Tribune | Aug 11, 2015 Urbanisation, rampant felling of trees to blame for the depletion  Over 1,500 billion cusecs of... Read More...
Boatmen demand to lift ban on boating in Ganga
Monday, 10 August 2015
TNN | Aug 9, 2015 VARANASI: After 11 days of imposing of ban on boat operations in Ganga by the district administration due to rise in water level,... Read More...
IMAGE Farakka under fire in India
Monday, 04 May 2015
Abu Bakar Siddique | Dhaka Tribune | May 3, 2015 Nine Indian citizens move an environment court, seeking over Rs3,000 crore in annual compensation... Read More...


We have 11 guests and no members online

This week272
This month1993

Wednesday, 17 January 2018 16:26

Follows us on FB

Go to top