The rejuvenation of tCitizens congregating on the banks of the Ganga during the Mahakumbh mela in 2013he Ganga figured prominently in the manifesto of the Bharatiya Janta Party, which took over the reins of power in May earlier this year. To show the party’s commitment to restore the Ganga, the Prime Minister elect (Narendra Modi) stood for elections from Varanasi, considered the holiest city along the banks of the river. He referred to the river as his mother and bowed in reverence. The symbolism didn’t stop there. The title of ‘Ministry of Water Resources’ was suffixed with the additional tag of ‘River Development and Ganga Rejuvenation.’ Political and media pundits saluted the initiative. 

Citizens congregating on the banks of the Ganga during the Mahakumbh mela in 2013

 

The Government even committed itself to maintain aviral (uninterrupted) flow, which gave environmentalists a flicker of hope that this initiative would be different from the Ganga Action Plan, launched in mid-1980 and widely considered an abject failure. At the time, the action plan sought to solely invest in the sewer network and treatment plants to deal with urban sewage run-off – all of which proved woefully inadequate. The government is now first and foremost interested in turning the river into a waterway. An inter ministerial panel tasked to oversee the rejuvenation project (including the Ministers of Environment, Tourism and Water resources) is being led by the Minister for Road Transport, Highways and Shipping. The minister has proposed a series of barrages (every 100 km) in a 1620 km stretch, known as “national waterway one,” with the intention to uniformaly dredge the river to a depth of 3 to 5 metres. There is much confusion surrounding this project which I will discuss in later paragraphs.

The current plan to revive the suffering Ganga does not detail how it will deal with the effluent of more than 2,000 grossly polluting industries along the main river stem (besides tributaries) nor the sewage from towns and cities (less than half of which is currently treated). There is big talk that industries will be turned into zero discharge campuses, but similar efforts in the past have failed due to expenses incurred and technological snags. The government is throwing more money down the drain; there has been little learning from the failure of previous action plans as investments in expensive sewerage infrastructure in towns and cities failed to expand as needed. This time around the approach remains the same, although the proposed investments have increased substantially. According to media reports, it is estimated that over the next eighteen years, the government will invest Rs 51,000 crore (approximately USD$8.5 billion) to deal with wastewater from 118 towns and cities in the river basin. Unfortunately, few low cost sewage treatment alternatives have been piloted, neither with the sincerity nor the urgency needed to give them a fair chance to succeed. The proposal makes no mention of employing inexpensive and less energy intensive options.  

To make matters worse, the administration continues to turn a blind eye towards destructive large hydropower dams in the headwaters of the river, which are not only impacting habitations downtream, but altering biodiversity, habitat and sediment flow. There is, however, a flicker of hope from a recent affadavit submitted to the Supreme Court of India. The Ministry of Environment and Forests has reportedly stated that the statutory clearances required for large dam projects will be given only after taking into account the possible impacts on efforts to rejuvenate the river. The ministry has proposed a new set of norms to ensure better longitudinal river connectivity and maintain sufficient environmental flows, i.e. water released downstream of a hydraulic structure. Some say that clearances will now be mandated for hydropower projects below 25 megawatts (currently exempted), something International Rivers and our partners have been advocating for. However, it remains to be seen whether or not any of these measures will be implemented in practice. 

The government has grand plans to restore “national waterway one,” a project environmentalists believe is in absolute contradiction to the Ganga rejuvenation mission. But here too there is much confusion. In a meeting on October 8, World Bank officials – the financiers of the project – explained that the proposal before them entails 4 barrages (not 16 as stated by the Minister for Road transport, highways and shipping) and that as per a study by the Danish Hydrological Institute, a 3 metre (not 5 metre) minimum depth will allow barges up to 2000 ton capacity to ply on the 1620 kilometre route. Submissions by a group of civil society members (including International Rivers) to the Government and World Bank has recommended that they study the impact of barrages on the transport of silt, the water budget, flora fauna and water quality, as well as undertake a cost benefit analysis and study the expected health impacts, among others. Setting up barrages at regular intervals will interfere with ecosystem services, all of which depend on maintaining adequate quality, volume and velocity of flow in the river. The project will additionally impose huge environmental and social costs, especially due to intensification of flood, riverbank and coastal erosion. The Bank has decided to commission three studies: a detailed feasibility analysis of alternative options, a cumulative impact assessment and a market development report for the sector. Expressions of interest have been called and the Bank is hoping to finalize consultants by early next year. 

Prime Minister Modi says the Ganga will be a model river in self-praise. But neither he nor his band of ministers have cared to hold broader consultations in an attempt to understand how disastrous the initiatives planned can be not only on river ecology but also on people dependent on the river for their livelihoods.  

Original Article on International Rivers Blog

Updates

Minutes of Meeting with World Bank-2nd September, 2015
Saturday, 12 September 2015
A meeting was held with World Bank officials on 2 September, 2015. Representations: Jayanto Bandopadhyaya, Vimal Bhai, Prahlad Goenka, Bharat... Read More...
Representation to World Bank on TORs for NW-1 Studies
Tuesday, 25 August 2015
August 13, 2015 Shri Arnab Bandopadhyay The World Bank New Delhi My Dear Arnab: We write in continuation of our earlier interactions regarding NW-1.... Read More...
Comments on TOR for NW-1 Studies Submitted to Inland Waterways Authority of India
Tuesday, 25 August 2015
DR BHARAT JHUNJHUNWALA Lakshmoli, PO Maletha, Via Kirti Nagar, Dt Tehri UK 249 161 Phone: 99171-44777; Email: bharatjj@gmail.com August 13, 2015 Shri... Read More...
IMAGE Ganga Rejuvenation Must Go Beyond Lip Service
Saturday, 18 October 2014
Bharat Lal Seth | Fri, 10/17/2014 - 3:35pm | International Rivers   The rejuvenation of the Ganga figured prominently in the manifesto of the... Read More...
IMAGE Let the River Take its Course
Tuesday, 30 September 2014
Written by Ramaswamy R Iyer | Posted: September 30, 2014 2:10 am | The Indian Express Soon after the prime minister assumed... Read More...
IMAGE World Rivers Day and Ganga: A look at Farakka Barrage and other such calamities
Tuesday, 30 September 2014
Parineeta Dandekar | 29th September, 2014 | SANDRP   Last Sunday of every September is celebrated as ‘World Rivers Day’. It is a recent... Read More...
Water resources depleting in Ganga catchment area: Study
Wednesday, 12 August 2015
B.D. Kasniyal | The Tribune | Aug 11, 2015 Urbanisation, rampant felling of trees to blame for the depletion  Over 1,500 billion cusecs of... Read More...
Boatmen demand to lift ban on boating in Ganga
Monday, 10 August 2015
TNN | Aug 9, 2015 VARANASI: After 11 days of imposing of ban on boat operations in Ganga by the district administration due to rise in water level,... Read More...
IMAGE Farakka under fire in India
Monday, 04 May 2015
Abu Bakar Siddique | Dhaka Tribune | May 3, 2015 Nine Indian citizens move an environment court, seeking over Rs3,000 crore in annual compensation... Read More...

Visitors

We have 27 guests and no members online

9.png3.png5.png9.png3.png
Today88
Yesterday77
This week418
This month1721
Total93593

Friday, 20 October 2017 19:52

Follows us on FB

Go to top